Review ~ In Another Life

Posted January 22, 2016 by Grace @ Rebel Mommy Book Blog in Reviews / 38 Comments

I received this book for free from Publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Review ~ In Another LifeIn Another Life by Julie Christine Johnson
Published by Sourcebooks Landmark on February 2nd 2016
Genres: Fiction, Historical, Romance
Pages: 368
Format: eARC
Source: Publisher via Netgalley
3 Stars

Historian Lia Carrer has finally returned to southern France, determined to rebuild her life after the death of her husband. But instead of finding solace in the region's quiet hills and medieval ruins, she falls in love with Raoul, a man whose very existence challenges everything she knows about life--and about her husband's death. As Raoul reveals the story of his past to Lia, she becomes entangled in the echoes of an ancient murder, resulting in a haunting and suspenseful journey that reminds Lia that the dead may not be as far from us as we think.
Steeped in the rich history and romantic landscape of rural France, In Another Life is a story of love that conquers time and the lost loves that haunt us all.


I usually do a little recap paragraph in my own words. This one is hard because at times I am not sure what was going on. I will some it up like this – widow finds love again while in Southern France researching and ancient assassination when past and present collide. Got it? Ok then.

You know me right? No? Maybe? Well you might have guessed that this cover, this beautiful cover, made me have to have this book. Plus, time travel you say? Southern France?? OH MY GOD. I was so damn ready for this book it was nuts. Then I started it and had no freaking clue what was going on for entire parts. Still, I enjoyed some aspects. Let’s break it down.

Things I liked:

Lia. She was a wonderful main character. Smart, strong-willed, a good friend. I enjoyed following her story.

Setting. I mean Southern France and vineyards. I so wanted to be transported there. The descriptions were wonderful and I could picture all the landscapes and churches and cottages so clearly.

Romance. Past meets present love affair. Yes please.

Rose. Rose was Lia’s best friend who is American but met and married a wine maker and moved to France. She extends her vacation house close by to Lia for however long she needs, She invites her to dinners and to talk and whatever else she needs in light of her husband’s passing. She was really just an amazing friend.

Things I didn’t like:

Pacing. This moved along too slow for me. I needed more to happen quicker.

Too much history. I know a lot of this is based on some historical stuff mixed with fiction. Still, a lot of detail was given, and names of places and people. Plus, since they were all French or similar ancient language it was hard for me to keep it all down which brings me to my next point . . .

Story/mystery confusing. I think my point above feeds into this. All the detail, plus jumps constantly from present to past confused the living daylights out of me. I had to reread sections. Sometimes I was still a bit muddled but just went with it. I eventually got it all ( I think).

Third person. I don’t think stories written in the third person usually bother me at all but this didn’t work for me as much. I would have loved Lia’s point of view even if the rest was done in an alternate third person.

All in all, it comes out about even, hence the 3 rating. I just wanted to love this one so much but it ultimately moved a little too slow and was a bit too hard for me to follow at times. Still, that cover gets an A+ in my book and may be the prettiest I have ever seen.  And that counts in my book.

Grace @ Rebel Mommy Book Blog

Tags: , , ,

38 responses to “Review ~ In Another Life

  1. Wow! That cover is stunning! And I’m with you! I would totally read the book because of the Southern France setting. I’m glad that the romance and the main character worked for you.
    I struggle with 3rd person sometimes myself. Sometimes it just doesn’t fit a story according to me. And that sucks about the too much history. That would probably annoy me too!
    Great review, Grace!
    Nick recently posted…Reading Kit & Audiobook Review: Surviving Ice by K.A. TuckerMy Profile

  2. It’s such a letdown when a book seems to have all the elements to be a total YOU book, but then just doesn’t get there. Your description of not knowing what was going on for entire parts… ugh. That frustrates me to no end and there’s only so long I’m willing to go on like that. Glad there was still enough to enjoy – but too bad this wasn’t a bigger hit for you.
    Tanya recently posted…Review: After You by Jojo MoyesMy Profile

  3. Darn, that is one seriously gorgeous cover, matched with an equally alluring blurb! But I totally get it with the monotonous detail and historical aspect to it… that’s made me DNF books before! Great review! 🙂

  4. That cover is so pretty! I would have been drawn in by it alone! And Southern France? Past meets present love affair? That sounds so good! But that stinks about the pacing and the third person. I think those two things would drive me crazy too. I’m all for historical fiction, but there is such a thing as TOO MUCH. I’m sorry this didn’t quite work out for you Grace!
    Jessica recently posted…Review: Everything, Everything by Nicola YoonMy Profile

  5. I admit, I am tempted to rush and pick this one up right now based on the cover and the fact that it is set in France alone. And I have to say, I also am not the hugest fan of third person. It works wonders in some books, but other just need that personal touch of first person, you know? Lovely review, as always ❤
    Erin recently posted…Comic Book Reviews IIMy Profile

  6. I”m sorry this one was a let down, Grace. That’s always so disappointing when you have high hopes for a book – particularly when the cover is so awesome! 😉 It does seem like an okay story – it’s too bad the pacing was off and the author added in a little too much history. Nice review, though. 😀
    Bookworm Brandee recently posted…Early Review ~ Getting Rough ~ C.L. ParkerMy Profile

  7. OH MY THIS BOOK IS SO PRETTY. I have a lot of cover love for this. This book sounds really interesting – but I definitely agree with the history, too much of it, and it’ll lag the book down. That’s usually the only problem I have with Dan Brown books. The mystery sounds intriguing though – I’ll be checking this book out in the near future. Lovely review, Grace! <3
    Nirvana recently posted…fortunate happenstances, tea & other thingsMy Profile

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge